6 Reasons to Bet Against Motorola

by Michael Comeau on April 20, 2010

I rarely make unhedged options trades, but yesterday I bought a chunk of Motorola (MOT) July $6 puts. This is a bet that Motorola’s stock price will drop by more than 20% by July – preferably by April 29th when the company reports Q1 earnings.

Here are 5 reasons I’m betting against Motorola.

1) Last Quarter Stunk

Despite having a very hot product in its Droid smartphone, Motorola reported a pretty lousy fourth-quarter earnings report, complete with a lousy outlook for Q1.

2) Android Competition at Verizon is Heating Up

The Droid has been the hot Google (GOOG) Android phone at Verizon Wireless, but that’s about to change. Two superior Android devices, the HTC Droid Incredible and the Google Nexus One will soon be sold at Verizon, and that’s going to cut into Droid sales.


3) Apple (AAPL) is Likely to Release a New iPhone This Summer

Apple has released a new iPhone model every summer for the past three years, and that my friend is a pattern. Plus, Gizmodo just released a report unveiling what is almost definitely a prototype for a new iPhone. This phone will definitely rule at AT&T (T). And if it makes it way to Verizon – issue $#2 is an even bigger problem for Motorola.

4) The Stock is Up In the Face of Bad News

Motorola’s stock price has jumped about over 25% off the January lows despite the fact that there has been nothing but lousy news since then. Competition in the smartphone market has gotten so bad that Palm (PALM) is hanging on for dear life despite having quality products, and the Android-phone market is quickly becoming oversaturated, with even Lenovo throwing its hat into the mix.

5) Motorola Has a Big Legacy Dumb Phone Business

The smartphone market is showing pretty decent growth, but the non-smartphone portion of the mobile-phone market is quickly stagnating. MOT’s dumb phone weakness has been enough to offset the strength of the Droid, and there’s no reason to think that will change soon.

6) Smartphone Pricing is in the Crapper

With the exception of the iPhone, smartphones have become so commodottized that you can pretty get a decent one for a penny on Amazon. Consumers do not value commodity phones, thus we should not value the stocks of commodity-phone producers.

Disclosure: short MOT through put options, long AAPL stock, long RIMM stock

P.S. Are you by any chance a fan of mixed martial arts? If so – read my review of BJ Penn’s new book Why I Fight

Related posts:

  1. Google’s Ultimate Sin
  2. My Top Mobile Phone Stock Picks
  3. Motorola DROID Price Drop At Amazon.com

{ 1 trackback }

Tweets that mention 6 Reasons I'm Shorting Motorola -- Topsy.com
April 22, 2010 at 2:07 pm

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: